« November 2008 | Main

December 15, 2008

Madoff, Warning Signs, and Split Strike Conversions.

Recent News Emphasizes Importance of Due-Diligence

Over the past few days, you have obviously been reading of the Madoff case.  It is stunning to hear of the impact and how far-reaching this situation has become.  From all indications, Madoff was a "stand up guy" that everyone implicitly trusted.  His assets under management and roster of investors would never give anyone the slightest clue that he might be up to no good.  But to everyone's surprise, he was in fact no good - in fact he's a fraud. 

Its this kind of situation that usually gets investors to reconsider the importance of due-diligence.  Not only should investors have a sound understanding of a money management firm's business model but also make sure that all the firms operating activities make sense.  Always keep your eyes open for "warning signs." 

With that said, I want to take this time to discuss three "warning signs" that can sometime pop up when dealing with a hedge fund money manager:

1.  Madoff's feeder funds marketed a "Split Strike Conversion" strategy. 

Lesson:  Make sure you understand the basic premise of the trader's strategy.  Understand that I am not saying that complex models are bad...but rather, if it is complex, make sure that you can generally explain the money-making tools.  Are they a long-only shop?  Do they trade S&P futures?  Or is some type of statistical arbitrage system? 

Bottom line:  If you hear the words "black box" and/or "proprietary" too much then ask more questions. (By the way, nothing drives me crazier than hearing managers using the word "black box" to describe their techniques.  Its overly-generic and way overused these days.)

2. Madoff not only managed client assets but initiated trades in client accounts, executed the trades, custodied those assets, constructed his own client statements and administered the paperwork.  There were no other parties involved - this is a clear red-flag!

Lesson:  Unless you are dealing with a Goldman or UBS size firm, then for the most part, it is a good idea to separate your trading manager from the custodial services.  Ensuring a strict segregation between these two functions can go a long way towards deterring any wrongdoing.   

3.  At the end of every quarter, Madoff's 13F filing showed very little in the way of equity holdings.  And when questioned as to why, their response" "...we go into cash at the end of every quarter..."

Lesson:  I can see this happening every now and then, but to have your hedge fund go into cash at the end of every quarter doesn't sound very efficient.  If your hedge fund has to file a 13F always spend time reviewing it once it is filed.


What is the Split Strike Conversion strategy?  

In the past few days, I have also had a number of clients ask me to explain to them the "Split Strike Conversion" strategy that Madoff marketed to his investors.

Split Strike Conversion defined:

Typically, the strategy consists of the simultaneous ownership of 30-35 S&P 100 stocks, the sale of out-of-the-money calls on the index and the purchase of out-of-the-money puts on the index. The sale of the calls is designed to increase the rate of return, while allowing upward movement of the stock portfolio to the strike price of the calls. The puts, funded in large part by the sale of the calls, limit the portfolio’s downside. The strategy creates a boundary on a stock or basket of stocks, limiting its upside while at the same time protecting against a sharp price decline.

Long story short:  Put a collar around a basket of S&P 100 stocks.

A fair number of institutional managers long questioned how Madoff could pull off such consistent risk-adjusted returns.  I guess when it seems too good to be true then it probably is. 



December 13, 2008

That Was Then and This Is Now. Beware of the Treasury Bond Bubble!

Irrational market in Treasuries push yield to all-time lows

At this point you probably asking yourself, "what does he mean by the title of the post?"

Just recently I wrote of how the S&P dividend yield was higher than that of the 10-year Treasury bond.  At the time of writing that article it was at 3.57%. 

Today the yield for the 10-year Treasury bonds sits at 2.57%. 

I have one word: BUBBLE!

Lets reference a recent Bloomberg snapshot of the current yields in the Treasury market:

U.S. Treasuries

                       COUPON    MATURITY    CURRENT  PRICE/YIELD    PRICE/YIELD CHANGE  
3-MONTH          0.000       03/12/2009    0.01 / .01                                 0 / .000   
6-MONTH          0.000       06/11/2009    0.2 / .20                                   0.02 / .020   
12-MONTH        0.000       11/19/2009    0.45 / .46                                 0 / -.000   
2-YEAR              1.250      11/30/2010    100-30+ / .76                           0-01 / -.018  
3-YEAR              1.125      12/15/2011    100-08½ / 1.03                        0-07 / -.074   
5-YEAR              2.000      11/30/2013    102-10+ / 1.51                         0-05 / -.033   
10-YEAR            3.750      11/15/2018    110-08½ / 2.57                         0-09 / -.031   
30-YEAR           4.500       05/15/2038    128-05½ / 3.04                         0-12+ / -.017      

Investors seeking safety from losses in equity markets charged the Treasury zero percent interest when the government sold $30 billion of four-week bills on Dec. 9th.  That was the same day that three-month bill rates turned negative for the first time since the US began selling debt in 1929. 

With that said, I am very bearish on the near-term outlook of treasuries.   This relentless frenzy to buy treasuries reminds me very much of the tech bubble in 2000.

In fact, I am hearing that many large hedge funds are beginning to short Treasury Bonds with the notion that they are way overbought.  And in this case, I agree.

My advice to new buyers of government paper: Beware!

Opinions

Subscribe

  • Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

Stay in Touch

  • Be sure to subscribe to my newsletter to stay in touch with my site. Over the course of this month, I will be adding downloadable excel spreadsheets that will allow investors to manipulate the financials for Goldman, Lehman, and Merrill. I will also be live-blogging their earnings conference calls in the upcoming months.



    Find Blogs in the Blog Directory My Zimbio
    Top Stories Business Top Blogs Finance Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory









Videos

  • Marc Faber on Bubbles

    Greenspan on credit problem

More Videos

  • I am always fascinated by successful entrepreneurs and the wisdom they provide. With that said, I am a big fan of, the Stanford educated, Peter Thiel, founder of Paypal and now hedge fund manager of Clarium Capital, a global macro venture capital fund he launched in 2005. He was an early investor in Facebook and sits on the company's board of directors. He is also an investor in Slide, LinkedIn and Friendster. You can download a great writeup of him right HERE.

Pages

  • About Me
  • Opinions
  • Resources
  • Valuation Models